Counting sprouts

13126964 - fresh green brussels sprouts isolated on white backgroundBizarrely, it is alleged that Southern Health is recommending COUNTING VEGETABLES as a therapy for depression. Being the festive season, sprouts should be readily to hand!

Sarah Ghafoor had suffered with depression for around 20 years and had previously made attempts to take her life. However, during an Inquest into her death, her family alleged she had been told by mental health professionals to COUNT VEGETABLESwhen she felt overwhelmed by her son, Ben’s death.

Sarah was prescribed a cocktail of anti-depressants and was seen by mental health staff at Southern Health as she struggled to cope with Ben’s death. She made three attempts to take her own life after his death on March, 12 2018. Her daughter-in-law told the Court Sarah had just wanted ‘someone to help’ but had been let down by Southern Health:

“She needed someone she could phone, not someone who told her to count vegetables – her son had died.

“I called Southern Health begging for help and they were horrific to me on the phone. If there were like that to me, how would she have felt?”

Read more here→

Another of Southern Health’s bright ideas for therapy (this time in conjunction with Southampton City Council) is CLEANING COUNCIL HOUSES. This came about after we proposed two proven outdoor therapies, to which a CMHT Manager responded:

Girl Plumb Dirty Toilet


“I thought about the supported housing projects in Southampton and many [with] no cleaning services. I was wondering if we could work together with Employment support to engage individuals in recovery to do some of this work.” 




So CLEANING COUNCIL HOUSES is apparently good for patients’ self-esteem. Cleaners we know laughed at the thought – it is more likely to have the opposite effect. Also, if patients have understanding employers, who allowed them time to recover from mental illness and the employers discover their employees are doing cleaning work for the Council, they will assume the patients are fit to return to work – if only to clean their workplace. I also suspect Southampton Council’s motives – cheap (or free?) labour. Sounds more like modern slavery to me! I wonder if they get paid at all? 

Now for ideas for open-air therapy proposed to Southern Health by CRASH:


Beach Cleaning


Not our original idea, but we were extremely impressed by Marine Biologist, Emily Stevenson, who appeared on Sky News on 22 September 2018 to promote her Beach Guardian initiative in Cornwall to tackle the scourge of plastic on our shores. Business owner Rob Stevenson and his  daughter Emily set up Beach Guardian originally in 2017.


Rob and Emily soon recognised that the region’s mental health was also in crisis with time off work due to mental health issues doubling in the past year, to the point where NHS figures show that Cornwall has seen one of the biggest increases in the country. Rob and Emily saw a way of addressing both problems with Beach Guardian. Read more→

And what’s more, CRASH received a potential offer of external funding for this therapy.




Or if fresh air on the beach doesn’t suit – go into the New Forest and walk with Alpacas. Read more here at footnote² →.




So which do you think is more beneficial to mental health patients?

Walk in the forest and on the beach – or counting sprouts and cleaning Council Houses!


Operation Scorch


Fire and flames.

Can you help detectives investigating the rape of a teenager in Southampton?

On Sunday, 2 December 2018, an 18-year-old woman was assaulted between 11pm and 11.50pm in Riverside Park just off of Woodmill Lane, Southampton.  Her name cannot be revealed for legal reasons. Read more here→.

So why, you may ask, it this relevant to Southern Health? Unforgivably, there is an alleged rapist at large as a result of its failure to report the alleged rape of a patient.

The Inquest into the death of Ellie Brabant, revealed that she returned to Antelope House, alleging she had been raped. Southern Health failed to report the allegation to the police.  CRASH believes the police would like to eliminate Ellie’s alleged rapist from their inquiries into the latest incident. It is only a possibility but such inquiries might also lead belatedly to an investigation into Ellie’s alleged rapist.

The Coroner’s Regulation 28 Prevention of Future Deaths Report on Ellie’s death identified this. The report by the charity Inquest records also that Southern Health:

  • Contaminated the scene of Ellie’s death by allowing her room to be cleaned before the police had finished their work.
  • Withheld a key document from the Coroner¹, Counsel for the family, and (to his great embarrassment) Counsel for the Trust. The Coroner’s diligence led to this being remedied on the last day of hearing verbal evidence: the document was key. 

Even more alarmingly sources close to Hampshire Constabulary inform us that Southern Health did not make a police report even after receiving the Coroner’s report.

Therefore, if you have any information, material or CCTV footage that can help in either incident, please dial 101 quoting Operation Scorch (Crime Number 44180450724). You can email too using these references We are sure it will be well-received. Please read on for more details.

Police Rape Map


For the assault on Sunday, 2 December 2018, the police have issued the route they believe the man they are hunting may have taken. Larger image here.

If any readers were in this area on 2 December and/or have any other information, they should contact the police.



The Coroner’s Regulation 28 Report and the charity Inquest’s report on Ellie Brabant says much about alleged improvements at Southern Health.

Even in the era of Katrina ‘Teflon’ Percy, I don’t recall, for example:

  • An informal patient telling clinical staff she had been raped, whilst away from the unit, and the Trust (?) not reporting it to the police. ***
  • An informal patient allowed to continue taking leave when she was returning high on drugs and/or drink and admitting to prostituting herself to raise the money.
  • The Trust (?) failing to secure the scene of an unexpected death before the police had finished their work. ***

I do recall late disclosure of evidence being criticised by a Coroner but, on this occasion, it was only the diligence of the Coroner, who discovered evidence on the last day of hearing, that the Trust had withheld a vital document. ***

22032231 - grumpy old judge in extreme wide angle closeup with hammer and wig*** Does failing to report alleged rape; failing to secure the scene; and withholding a key document from a Coroner, fulfil CPS Charging Standards for Perverting the Course of Justice² or Misconduct in Public Ofice³?


The charging decision is made by the police, working with the Crown Prosecutor. But, everyone can form an opinion⁴ using the information and links in footnotes 2 & 3. 

Finally, a reminder that BBC South Today’s report on the Inquest, is available here→.  

And for those who came to the Southern Health saga late, the BBC documentary ‘Broken Trust’ is now available too – here→.

¹ Senior Coroner, Mr Grahame A Short

² Perverting the Course of Justice is a common law offence committed when an accused:
does an act or series of acts; which has or have a tendency to pervert; and which is or are intended to pervert; the course of public justice. The course of justice starts when:
an event has occurred, from which it can reasonably be expected that an investigation will follow. The Trust knows there will be an Inquest and a police inquiry after an unexpected death so the question of reasonable expectation does not even arise. 

³ Misconduct in Public Office is a common law offence, which is committed when: a public officer acting as such; wilfully neglects to perform his duty and/or wilfully misconducts himself; to such a degree as to amount to an abuse of the public’s trust in the office holder; without reasonable excuse or justification. It normally includes elements of dishonesty, concealment and cover-up. It is often used when an alternative offence does not give the Court adequate sentencing powers.

DISCLAIMER – facts around the incidents described in this post are attributed (as shown) to the Coroner and Hampshire Police. Related observations are opinion only and should not be interpreted as implying any misconduct on the part of any individual persons or persons. That is a matter for the CPS, police and/or relevant Regulators.